FARMINGVILLE'S PIZZERIA SINCE 2010
Goomba Johnny's
Pizza, Pasta & Parms
in Farmingville, NY.
New York-style round, Brooklyn, Grandma, Sicilian and specialty pies, plus heroes, pasta and parms. Made on Mooney Pond Road since 2010. We deliver to Farmingville, Selden, Centereach, Coram and nearby towns, promptly and with care.
Open Daily, 11 AM–9 PM
Pickup and delivery every day of the week
Delivery Within 6 Miles
Prompt, handled with care and kept warm
Order Direct, Earn Rewards
Earn 10 points for every $1 spent on direct orders
GOOMBA REWARDS
Join Rewards.
Earn free food + a free pizza on your birthday.
GET
250
WELCOME POINTS
when you join
EARN
10
POINTS
for every $1 spent on direct orders
DOUBLE
2X
POINTS
on Tuesdays
WHAT YOUR POINTS GET YOU
750 points
Free slice + soda
1,750 points
Free hero, pasta, roll or calzone
3,000 points
Free large cheese pizza, 6 garlic knots + 2‑liter soda
MADE FRESH DAILY
Farmingville Favorites
The pies and plates our regulars order by name.
Grandma, Sicilian & Spicy Nonna
Thin and crisp, thick and airy, or topped with vodka sauce, pepperoni cups and hot honey — our square-pan classics.
Goomba, Brooklyn & Meat Lovers
From our vodka-sauce Goomba pie to fresh-mozzarella Brooklyn and loaded Meat Lovers — three very different ways to do a round pie.
The Goomba Hero, Parms & Hot Heroes
The Goomba Hero on garlic bread, chicken and meatball parms, cheesesteaks and classic hot heroes.
Pasta & Baked Dishes
Pasta Alla Vodka, Rigatoni Mamma Mia and pasta classics, plus baked ziti, lasagna and stuffed shells.
Salads
Caesar, Greek, antipasto and garden salads, plus our Fried Chicken Honey Mustard Salad.
Wings & Appetizers
Our 12-wing special, mozzarella sticks, rice balls, baked clams, fried calamari and stuffed garlic knots.
FEED THE WHOLE HOUSE
Family Combo Deals
Dinner sorted for the whole table. Pick a combo and order it in one tap.
Family Combo #1
$35.75
$35.75
- 1 Large Cheese Pie
- 1 Penne Alla Vodka
- 1 Side Salad
Family Combo #2
$43.95
$43.95
- 1 Large Cheese Pie
- 1 Baked Ziti
- 1 Side Salad
- 6 Garlic Knots
Family Combo #3
$99.95
$99.95
- 12 Garlic Knots
- Pick 3 Rolls
- 2 Large Cheese Pies
- 20 Wings
- 1 Large Salad
Family Combo #4
$120.95
$120.95
- 1/2 Tray Chicken Parmigiana
- 1/2 Tray Penne Alla Vodka
- 1/2 Tray Salad
- 1/2 Tray Garlic Knots
PARTIES · OFFICES · TEAMS
Catering Packages
for every size crowd.
CATERING PACKAGE #1
$69.95
- Choose one 1/2 tray: Chicken Alfredo, Chicken Parmigiana, or Penne Alla Vodka with Chicken
- Includes 2-Liter Coke
- 6 Garlic Knots
CATERING PACKAGE #2
$119.95
- Pick 3 Rolls
- 12 Garlic Knots
- 3 Large Cheese Pies
- 30 Wings
CATERING PACKAGE #3
$149.95
- 30 Wings
- Two 2-Liter Sodas
- 3 Large Cheese Pizzas
- 24 Garlic Knots
- 1/2 Tray Penne Alla Vodka
- 1/2 Tray House or Caesar Salad
CATERING PACKAGE #4
$179.95
- 1/2 Tray Chicken Parmigiana
- 2 Large Cheese Pizzas
- 1/2 Tray Penne Alla Vodka
- 24 Garlic Knots
- 1/2 Tray House Salad
CATERING PACKAGE #5
$279.95
- 1/2 Tray Chicken Parmigiana
- 1/2 Tray Penne Alla Vodka
- 1/2 Tray Chicken Wings
- 1/2 Tray House or Caesar Salad
- 1/2 Tray Garlic Knots
- 12 Meatballs
CATERING PACKAGE #6
$479.95
- 2 Large Cheese Pies
- Full Tray Chicken Parmigiana or Francese
- Full Tray Penne Alla Vodka or Baked Ziti
- Full Tray Chicken Wings
- Full Tray Garlic Knots
- 3 Two-Liter Sodas
- 4 Heroes
GIFT CARDS
Give the gift of Goomba Johnny's.
Digital gift cards for pizza, pasta and parms, good for pickup, delivery and catering.
OUR STORY
Made on Mooney Pond Road
since 2010.
Goomba Johnny’s has made pizza on Mooney Pond Road in Farmingville since 2010. We make New York-style round pies along with Brooklyn, Grandma, Sicilian, Neapolitan and specialty pizzas — plus heroes, parms, pasta and baked Italian favorites. From our Brooklyn pie with crushed Romano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, Romano and basil to Grandma and thick-crust Sicilian pies, there’s a style for just about every pizza night.
Everything is made fresh every day at 374 Mooney Pond Road, for pickup, delivery or catering. We deliver to Farmingville, Selden, Centereach, Coram, Holtsville, Medford, Holbrook, Lake Ronkonkoma and Terryville. A slice at lunch, pies for the family, The Goomba Hero or Penne Alla Vodka, or trays for the team — same Farmingville kitchen, same recipes our regulars order by name.
WE DELIVER
Pizza Delivery Near You
We deliver within about 6 miles of 374 Mooney Pond Road, promptly and kept warm. Find your town:
WHAT NEIGHBORS SAY
Loved in Farmingville
★★★★★ 5.0
“Great pizza, plenty of options by the slice, and top notch service. Simple, fast, and done right. Exactly what you hope for when you walk into a pizzeria. …”
Alex T. · Google review
★★★★★ 5.0
“By far, my favorite pizzeria! There’s something about the sauce that makes me keep coming back! … There’s nothing quite the same as Goomba Johnny’s.”
Rosanna B. · Google review
★★★★★ 5.0
“Finally got my fix! Awesome Buffalo Chicken pie and garlic knots!”
Clarissa A. · Google review
GOOD TO KNOW
Frequently Asked Questions
Do you deliver to Selden, Centereach and Coram?
Yes. Goomba Johnny's delivers within about 6 miles of our Farmingville shop at 374 Mooney Pond Road, including Selden, Centereach, Coram, Holtsville, Medford, Holbrook, Lake Ronkonkoma and Terryville. Every order is handled with care and kept warm.
How do Goomba Rewards work?
Join free and get 250 welcome points, then earn 10 points for every $1 you spend ordering direct, with double points on Tuesdays. Points unlock a free slice and soda, a hero or pasta, or a large cheese pizza with 6 garlic knots and a 2-liter soda, and members get a free pizza on their birthday.
What are your hours?
We're open every day from 11 AM to 9 PM.
What kind of pizza does Goomba Johnny’s make?
Goomba Johnny’s makes New York-style round pies, Brooklyn, Grandma, Sicilian, Neapolitan and specialty pizzas, along with heroes, pasta, parms and classic pizzeria favorites.
What's the difference between a Grandma pie and a Sicilian pie?
A Grandma pie has a thin square crust with marinara sauce, mozzarella and grated cheese. A Sicilian pie has a thick, airy square crust with tomato sauce and mozzarella. Both are baked in square pans.
Do you cater?
Yes. We have catering packages for groups of every size, plus half and full trays of pasta, chicken, eggplant, salads and 3-foot heroes. Send a request on our Catering page or call (631) 736-0722.
Where is Goomba Johnny's?
374 Mooney Pond Road, Farmingville, NY 11738. Call (631) 736-0722.
VISIT US
On Mooney Pond Road
374 Mooney Pond Road
Farmingville, NY 11738
Every day 11 AM – 9 PM
